Does JKD work on the street

M

Mider

Brown Belt
Joined
May 15, 2012
Messages
433
Reaction score
97
Have you made JKD work on the street or in sparring vs boxers and BJJ guys? I remember Tim Tackett saying if it doesn’t work against a skilled opponent he doesn’t care to learn it.
 
I guess it depends what you mean by jkd. If you mean the overarching concept based philosophy laid out in his TJKD, then yes. Use what works, discard what doesn't and add what is your own.

If you mean the crystalized rigid thing it has become that doesn't put too much focus on aliveness..your milage may vary.
 
Like everything, it depends on how well it is trained. The style itself does not work. No style “works”. It is the person training the methodology that is able to use it effectively. Some people can, others cannot, and that is true of every system and style.

Are you considering training JKD? Do you have access to a skilled and knowledgeable instructor, w whom you have a good rapport and are comfortable working? Can you afford that fee? Do you find the method interesting, enough to keep you working at it without getting bored or losing that interest? If so, then give it a try. That is what matters.

There is no hypothetical “best” style. What is the best choice for you may be a terrible choice for someone else. The best choice is something that you will keep at, enthusiastically. If you lose interest and stop training, then it is a terrible choice for you, regardless of what others might think of it.

Find what is a good choice for you and then keep at it.
 
Don't now if it works in the street, my guess is it does if the person is well trained. I did have a teacher that said it worked rather well in a bar. He apparently got in a few bar fights before I knew him and JKD worked rather well
 
All things being equal, it does. However, discerning factors can make a difference. One such is speed. If you have incredible speed and only 1 kick, 1 block, and 1 punch then you will most likely win. Even that is questionable as I remember my old karate days and being in a 4 Seasons Tournament (Long Beach, Ca). My speed on a block was too fast and blocked nothing but air-then my opponent scored against me. Bummer and embarrassment. (That is why Sifu/Guru Dan Inosanto says "timing is more important than speed"!
Other factors make winners or losers too. Experience and mind-set, for example.
Remember: It's not the size of the dog in the fight-it's the size of the fight in the dog.
Sifu Mike
 
I’ve heard it de
Xue Sheng said:
Don't now if it works in the street, my guess is it does if the person is well trained. I did have a teacher that said it worked rather well in a bar. He apparently got in a few bar fights before I knew him and JKD worked rather well
Click to expand...
ive heard guys like Tim Tackett and Ted Wong are great teachers at teaching how to fight on the street.
 
Mider said:
I’ve heard it de

ive heard guys like Tim Tackett and Ted Wong are great teachers at teaching how to fight on the street.
Click to expand...

I have no doubt it does, I was only basing my response from what I was told by someone who trained JKD who was also in an unregulated fight. This teacher also believed it worked well in the street. It was just his unscheduled, unwanted fights, occured in a bar.

Bottomline, what this taught me was I never wanted to go to a bar with him :)
 
Mider said:
Have you made JKD work on the street or in sparring vs boxers and BJJ guys? I remember Tim Tackett saying if it doesn’t work against a skilled opponent he doesn’t care to learn it.
Click to expand...
A jackhammer is more effective on the street.
 
The real question is not the art... but the student and how well they trained the art. If you seriously train an art... it can work. Having trained it myself... and used it.... Well it worked for me. But maybe if I devoted the same time to Art X/Y or Z it would also.
It's basis is centered around being street effective.
And someone pointed out above.... Certain arts are definitely geared to different physical attributes. If you got bad hips for example... It's probably not a good choice to go into a art that relies heavily on kicking.
 
_Simon_ said:
But I think the REAL question is... which street?
Click to expand...
We used to spend summers on Cape Cod. In the town of Dennisport there was a street, Easy Street.

People stole that street sign ten times a summer. Looking back, I wish I had stolen one, too.
 
_Simon_ said:
Ah well... I'm sorry but nothing will help you there.
Click to expand...
It's right there in the theme song. Poor kids always begging to be told how to get there, every show.

I learned JKD from a professional Thai boxer. He thought it was cool, that's all that mattered.

Haven't needed to use it in the street yet, thankfully. If the time comes, I am so going to scream like Bruce Lee, hopefully my opponent will run away.
 
Sifu Mike said:
All things being equal, it does. However, discerning factors can make a difference. One such is speed. If you have incredible speed and only 1 kick, 1 block, and 1 punch then you will most likely win. Even that is questionable as I remember my old karate days and being in a 4 Seasons Tournament (Long Beach, Ca). My speed on a block was too fast and blocked nothing but air-then my opponent scored against me. Bummer and embarrassment. (That is why Sifu/Guru Dan Inosanto says "timing is more important than speed"!
Other factors make winners or losers too. Experience and mind-set, for example.
Remember: It's not the size of the dog in the fight-it's the size of the fight in the dog.
Sifu Mike
Click to expand...
There are many factors that make a great fighter, speed is definitely one of them, but reflects is the other. You can know all the moves in the world, be the strongest, but if your opponent is faster in speed and reflects, you do not have a chance.
 
The question is whether it works at all. Which should be pretty easy to tell.

The reason works on the street is not a great indicator is you probably won't see it working. Or see it working enough times to get a good idea.

Where if say some guys jab hits everyone in the room all the time and nobody has an answer to it. That is a much more reliable indicator.
 
Last edited:
drop bear said:
The question is whether it works at all. Which should be pretty easy to tell.

The reason works on the street is not a great indicator is you probably won't see it working. Or see it working enough times to get a good idea.

Where if say some guys jab hits everyone in the room all the time and nobody has an answer to it. That is a much more reliable indicator.
Click to expand...
Few people have ever been jabbed in the face. I mean really nailed. Most people don't know what that feels like.

So how could they possibly know how to react? Most people have no answer to a jab because they've never felt one, let alone had the time to dwell on it.
 
I used JKD in a couple of physical altercations I wasnt able to talk myself out of and it works fine, and within the confines of the law which is the trickiest part
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

JKD Question

Previous Thread

JKD/Jun Fan/Concepts? Bruce Lee himself?

Next Thread

Latest Discussions

Back
Top