Hi Brad,Brad Dunne said:It was said that Choi only had 10 kicks and they were all low.
If you check out the latest issue of Black Belt magazine, you'll see an article about the ten kicks that Choi taught GM Lim Hyun Soo of the Jungkikwan. GM Lim trained directly with Choi for over 20 years. One or two of the kicks are to targets above the waist, but the rest are low, as you say.
However, we can't say conclusively that Choi always taught these ten kicks to all of his students. We know from information available from various of Choi's direct students that he taught different material to different people at different times in his life. So, it's possible that he taught other kicks to other students, even though I'm not aware of any examples of this.
Unless I'm misunderstanding your meaning, I have to disagree with you here.Brad Dunne said:Old school TKD has roots in Hapkido...
Old-school TKD has its roots in Japanese and Okinawan Karate that some Koreans learned in Japan. They took what they had learned back to Korea and began teaching it after the end of the Japanese occupation. Most of them had trained in Shotokan.
Hapkido was just getting started in Korea at this time. Choi's first student in Korea began training under him in, I believe, 1947. I'm not aware of any of the original Korean Karate kwan heads studying under Choi Young Sool.
And, we can be sure that, whatever the art was that Choi learned in Japan, it was not Karate-based. There is very little similarity between Choi's original art and the Korean Karate that preceded the creation of TKD.
Regards, Howard