Different people probably, slightly different structure, same results at best. At worst, a whole lotta unnecessarily dead people if it doesn't fly. Then you end up reverting back to a stable (not necessarily desirable) structure.
That's another thing we differ on. It is necessary at times as unfortunate as that is. On the surface that statement may sound a bit harsh, but most will not give up their power over you otherwise. On a more simple and perhaps understandable level, think in terms of self-defense where it comes down to your life or the life of the attacker. Which life do you choose?
I also wonder, slaves in exactly what sense? No matter the structure you're going to end up with someone who wields power over another. You will have to move with their agenda on some level.
Complacency is a tool they've learned to use over the centuries.
Give the masses enough to pacify them, to distract them from their ills and they will not challenge your authority as often. However, they only want to give enough to accomplish this and at times screw up enough for enough people to notice to do something.
It's happened over and over again throughout history.
The Founding Fathers knew governmet naturally attracts the power hungry and hoped that the Bill of Rights and the Constitution would help to prevent that with the watchful eye of the people. But, the people... the most unpredictable variable... have failed.
Perhaps human beings are like sheep and need shepherds. Perhaps people can't handle the responsibility of freedom. Perhaps it is the best thing for us to have our lives ruled cradle to the grave. If that's true of the majority, it's definately not true for me. Let the rest of the world be ruled, just let me and those like me have at least one place where we can go to live free.
CC: The last time the government was controlled by the people, (a handful relative to the population even then) the nation hadn't been half formed yet. I get the impression you think the wrong side won the civil war. (I don't really see the enlightened self interest that must've been guiding the South's actions.)
This nation can still be controlled by the people. I don't think it's too late though the time is getting closer where it will take bloodshed to change it. Every time another right is trampled on, every time what is mine is taken without my consent, the second hand moves a little more.
It just depends on us and if we take advantage of the vast resources of informaton available and stop accepting what we're spoonfed by the mass media.
And you would be right. I'm not naive enough to think that the Civil War had anything to do with anything so noble as ending slavery. It wasn't, and even the most elementary historian knows that. It was about what we're discussing here...power and money. You don't have to agree of course, you can go on believing what the public schools taught you in 5th grade and go on believing what you've been spoon fed.