Cruentus
Grandmaster
Tgace: I guess I started this thread hi-jack so I apologize...I suppose the "spreading the art" topic should be on its own thread.
Well here is that new thread. Spreading the art...thoughts?
Have fun!
:asian:
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Tgace: I guess I started this thread hi-jack so I apologize...I suppose the "spreading the art" topic should be on its own thread.
Tgace said:You are an evil man... and I was called a troublemaker.
Agreed. That, as far as I am concerned, is to train well, teach well, lead by example. As has been stated on the origins of this spin off (you have trickster rabbit ears under a hat don't you Paul ), the problem that I see with focusing on 'spreading the art' as a primary goal is that you end up with watered down, over simplified, and sold off rank. THe business axium that a good product practically sells itself seems to be fairly sound.ARNIS PRINCESS said:Something that needs to be done or arts will become extinct.
Well, I don't see a problem with the structure that RP used (seminars, camps...small group/privates as possible) to instruct and the establish a base of qualified instructors to begin teaching MA in the states or where ever he was working. It becomes a problem when that beginning phase of growth building isn't changed into something else with a solid plan and structure.Tulisan said:For the rest, though, it seems that we have a dilemma. You go out and spread the art the way that RP did, and you risk a political mess that he had to face, and that we now face.
If you stay indoors and only teach in small groups or privates, then you really do rick your art dying off.
So we know the strengths and limitations of each. What is the solution to the dilemma?
:idunno: :asian:
StraightRazor said:Im new here. This is my first post as a matter of fact. But i have been lurking as a guest for a while. And I jump into a political thread (typical )
I notice that there seems to be more behind this thread than I can see on the surface. It started on the originating thread and seems to be brewing here too. A sort of simmering tension. Between players here. You guys know each other or somthin?
Okay, then who was your NYU instructor/system if you need/want a training group there are many here who would welcome a good training partner. Knowing your previous training might help find the best fit/group.StraightRazor said:Mr. Martin
To be straight up with you, my only training in FMA is from a college buddy of mine who taught me when I was in school @NYU. I have "rank" in TKD and Kenpo. Havent gotten back into anything since Ive come back. Been lurking here since I see a lot of people here list WNY as their location. Lots of "bad blood" I see from searching the posting history of some of you guys, didnt know it was like that in FMA.
This is so true in a lot of "commercial schools." What I find really disturbing is that now you have several generations of instructors, who were products of their own instructors and do not even know what they are missing.The problem is that the service product of Martial arts is more than selling a system, it is selling a presentor of that product as well. There is an element of the 'cult of personallity' in how a school/system/art is sold. So are we salesmen first and martial artists second? Are we evangelists or are we instructors? Promotion, sales, public relations are all necessary but are they the largest part of your 'doing business time'? We are not trained in 'advertising/marketing arts', but martial artists. Do that well, understand the market and do your best to present an honest, quality product (welcome/safe training environment and have a clear mission/goal/philosophy) and the people who fit the 'corporate culture' that you establish will be attracted by advertising, word of mouth and personal investigation.
I fear that 'spreading the art' as a primary goal has been too often used as a not so thinly veiled market goal of creating lots of well paying students instead of well instructed students.
StraightRazor said:Mr. Martin
Lots of "bad blood" I see from searching the posting history of some of you guys, didnt know it was like that in FMA.