Originally posted by Johnathan Napalm
In what way?
San shou is the Chinese version of MMA. It is a modern invention under the communist regime. It copied Bruce Lee's JKD by the truckload, and then combined with Mongolian wrestling or Suai Xiao (sp)
When San Shou fighters fought MT fighters under MT rules, they got cleaned. They were out fought and out classed. To quote one San SHou fighter, after his defeat," I have never been so severely beaten ever."
San Shou lacks in the elbow and knee department.
OTOH, may be it is just that those particular San Shou teams simply suck.
i suppose it would depend on what particular team you were watching. i've seen different variations of san shou myself. some of it is strikingly similar to your average karate point tournament....usually takes place in a gymnaisium type setting with mats on the ground with multiple events going on at the same time. not that impressive compared to any match in a ring, but i still wouldn't write it off as some tappy tournament fight.
then i've seen (more often) san shou bouts that take place in the ring, which are more reminiscent of muay thai.
i'll agree...san shou definitely does lack in the elbow department...since they don't throw them in competition...
knees have been added to the game however, and while i doubt many shan shou fighters would have the power of muay thai fighters at this point...i see no reason that they could not train themselves to become just as proficient in them.
then there is the stand-up grappling...which muay thai has, but there are also the takedowns and slams incorporated into it. of course you can learn this sort of thing somewhere else, you can learn a lot of things in multiple places.
it basically comes down to the trainers, the coaches, and ultimately the fighters and how much they are willing to put into it. as for it being the chinese version of MMA...i guess it's more like the chinese version of kickboxing to me...sure they have the takedowns but it doesn't go much further than that. modern invention...? i suppose. the communist regime? i guess they would be commies over there but i don't know much about that.
the point is that if someone was to go and train in a good san shou gym then i think it would benefit them. that's my opinion, you seem to disagree. fine with me.