Fight4Peace&Love!
White Belt
- Joined
- Jun 22, 2014
- Messages
- 14
- Reaction score
- 0
Is footwork vital to martial art?
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Are bears Catholic? Does the Pope... oh wait.Is footwork vital to martial art?
Is footwork vital to martial art?
Is footwork vital to martial art?
Is footwork vital to martial art?
Is footwork vital to martial art?
i was told by someone who got to meet, interview and work with many old generation chinese masters that it was always said if you wanted to judge someones ability in martial arts dont look at their upper body or arms look at their feet and foot work.
If my opponent is not moving, I'll just look at his back leg.if you wanted to judge someones ability in martial arts dont look at their upper body or arms look at their feet and foot work.
With respect to your instructor I would suggest he/she is only partially correct. The footwork you learn on the football field gives you great balance and ease of movement, essential for self defence. The footwork you learn in class is for many of the techniques you may use in your self defence such as trips, throws and takedowns. That is not to say the stances are not there if you don't study a traditional martial art, just that they are formally practised in certain martial arts.Yes and no
For studying martial arts, yes foot work is essential. If you are studying a martial art that has forms you going to learn some sort of foot work; if you are studying a weapon based art like Kendo, the FMAs, fencing etc. etc. etc. you are going to learn some sort of foot work; if you are studying a throwing art you are going to learn some sort of foot work; and so on and so on.
However in the very basic format, one of my instructor's has said, that for self defense related study all of the foot work a person really needs generally can be learned on the football field. Thus putting aside the need for the vast majority of ways foot work is stressed in learning martial arts (for SD related purposes).
With respect to your instructor I would suggest he/she is only partially correct. The footwork you learn on the football field gives you great balance and ease of movement, essential for self defence. The footwork you learn in class is for many of the techniques you may use in your self defence such as trips, throws and takedowns. That is not to say the stances are not there if you don't study a traditional martial art, just that they are formally practised in certain martial arts.
:asian:
In reality in a real fight feet will go where feet will go. That is a comfortable balanced position. That is why people have a go at TMAs for unrealistic stances. In a lot of sport sparring situations the only stance required is a natural fighting stance similar to a boxer's stance. It is only when you include grappling in the sparring that the TMA footwork is used. A wrestler will use the same footwork without formally training it. My training is all directed at self defence and all footwork I teach is all for self defence. In karate it is taught in a formal way, in Krav the exact same footwork is used but it is just taught as part of the technique.K-man
I understand your point and agree. I believe learning a martial art is different than learning self defense although there is some over lap. Generally (IMHO) we as martial artists tend to look at things through the martial art or martial sport lens (so to speak), which generally involve two mutual combatants engaging in combat. Whether it is in the octogan, the high school gym on the wrestling mat, the boxing ring, the Kendo match, or the local dojo in sparring class etc etc. Also depending upon how we teach kata, Anyos, forms, etc. etc. we teach foot work to deal with all of those types of situations. But for the most part the foot work that we work on for the contest part (mutual combatants), is what the majority of the foot work training is meant to deal with. It is in this context that what the instructor was saying I believe is correct.
His point being that much of the stance work and training we do in the martial arts has more place in the ring, the octogan or the dojo then really on the street. The evasion skills learned on the football field (USA football) had more practicality in regards to self defense than most traditional or sport martial arts foot work. I totally agree with your concluding sentence as I believe the instructor I quoted would as well.
In reality in a real fight feet will go where feet will go. That is a comfortable balanced position. That is why people have a go at TMAs for unrealistic stances. In a lot of sport sparring situations the only stance required is a natural fighting stance similar to a boxer's stance. It is only when you include grappling in the sparring that the TMA footwork is used. A wrestler will use the same footwork without formally training it. My training is all directed at self defence and all footwork I teach is all for self defence. In karate it is taught in a formal way, in Krav the exact same footwork is used but it is just taught as part of the technique.
:asian: