MartialMellow
Green Belt
- Joined
- Sep 27, 2013
- Messages
- 128
- Reaction score
- 7
What would you do if you started thinking that your M.A. school was pushing you through belt promotions too fast?A. Speak with the head instructor?B. Leave?C. Other?
Belt Promotions too Fast?
- Thread starter MartialMellow
- Start date
OP
MartialMellow
Green Belt
- Joined
- Sep 27, 2013
- Messages
- 128
- Reaction score
- 7
- Thread Starter
- #3
^ What is a mcdojo?
donald1
Senior Master
- Joined
- Jan 20, 2013
- Messages
- 3,557
- Reaction score
- 844
A school that promotes students that maybe are not yet at that rank,
Signs of mcdojo
- promised black belt, (in a good school they don't know if you'll make it to black belt)
- any deadly techniques(I've heard mcdojos don't teach them, not sure how true that is)
- children around the age 12 black belt
There's many other ways to find out too
Signs of mcdojo
- promised black belt, (in a good school they don't know if you'll make it to black belt)
- any deadly techniques(I've heard mcdojos don't teach them, not sure how true that is)
- children around the age 12 black belt
There's many other ways to find out too
Hong Kong Pooey
Blue Belt
- Joined
- Jul 6, 2013
- Messages
- 278
- Reaction score
- 96
It depends how hard they're pushing. I've felt like that sometimes but I usually just have an excuse as to why I can't do it this time. Our grading opportunities are usually only every few months or so though and usually on a weekend so it's not too difficult to put it off.
It's probably worth noting as well that some of us actually need pushing every now and then.
Danny T
Senior Master
Why would you Not Speak with your instructor and if not satisfied speak the head instructor or owner?
Jaeimseu
3rd Black Belt
I disagree a little with this one, for taekwondo at least. Anyone who walks into my school is able to earn a black belt. They simply have to put in the time and effort. I would never say, "You will be a black belt in x months/years," but I could easily give them an average time from white to black.
It all depends...
There is a HUGE difference between a belt factory with mandatory testing and "if you can afford it, we will award it" policies and an instructor who knows that a student is ready for promotion despite their insecurities.
In an ideal world, the student and instructor agree that it's time to promote. But frankly, I prefer the student who needs to be told "You're ready to test. Yes you are. Yes, I am sure you are" over the one who needs to be told "You're not ready to test. No, you're not. Yes, I am sure".
There is a HUGE difference between a belt factory with mandatory testing and "if you can afford it, we will award it" policies and an instructor who knows that a student is ready for promotion despite their insecurities.
In an ideal world, the student and instructor agree that it's time to promote. But frankly, I prefer the student who needs to be told "You're ready to test. Yes you are. Yes, I am sure you are" over the one who needs to be told "You're not ready to test. No, you're not. Yes, I am sure".
This is actually a very difficult question to answer. When you are a student in a dojo, you have no say as to how and why the instructors do anything concerning testing. I can't see how speaking with the instructor about belt promotions is going to do anything. If the instructor is part of what we call a "belt factory" he isn't going to be doing cartwheels over questioning his methods of testing, if it's not a belt factory - the questions won't apply. So....I dunno'.
I always had a policy when in charge of testing and belts. And every single student in the school was taught it from day one. "If you ask about when you will be tested or when your next belt will come, or any question related to that - it's an automatic six months longer added on. No exceptions. So shut up and train." (yes, I used the shut up and train cliché)
I consider belt factories criminal. I don't know how they sleep at night. I really don't. All I can figure is they have no love for Martial Arts. None at all.
I always had a dislike for people that thought they should have the next belt and if they told me they should be testing they seemed to fail always.
On the other hand I respected students that said they felt they where not ready to take the next test. Some times I had them test anyway and sometimes I let them wait until i tested again. Some I tested as a part of a normal class and never told them they where testing until the night was over and I awarded them the belt.
NOW as to the OP, If your not ready to test tell the instructor your not ready and feel it would be better to wait. If you feel it necessary talk to the instructor and ask whet requirments are for each belt. Tell him you feel you need more time in rank to learn before you test.
Just a couple question do you pay for tests and dose the price go up each time? Are test given to everyone in the school at certain intervals (3,4,5, months)? Dose everyone pass the test each time?
On the other hand I respected students that said they felt they where not ready to take the next test. Some times I had them test anyway and sometimes I let them wait until i tested again. Some I tested as a part of a normal class and never told them they where testing until the night was over and I awarded them the belt.
NOW as to the OP, If your not ready to test tell the instructor your not ready and feel it would be better to wait. If you feel it necessary talk to the instructor and ask whet requirments are for each belt. Tell him you feel you need more time in rank to learn before you test.
Just a couple question do you pay for tests and dose the price go up each time? Are test given to everyone in the school at certain intervals (3,4,5, months)? Dose everyone pass the test each time?
I think it is ridiculous for a M.A. school to push students through belt promotions. Its the students that have to push themselves. And some students don't care about rank, they might be joining the martial arts for other reasons, maybe they want to lose weight, maybe they want to get in good shape, martial arts training is good for that.
And here is how you determine if a martial arts school is a McDojo. Observe a class and if the high ranking students perform terribly than you know its a McDojo.
And here is how you determine if a martial arts school is a McDojo. Observe a class and if the high ranking students perform terribly than you know its a McDojo.
So do you clarify this policy with students when they sign up? Maybe a student might not be clear on how rank advancement works in your school since every school has their own system of rank. As for shutting up and training, that's for when you're doing drills.
I see what you mean. I once had a college professor who said that he would sometimes have students that would come to his class and tell him that they always get A's in their classes and that they should have no problem getting an A in his class. He didn't like those students that much. On the other hand he did respect students who would tell him that they would like to get an A in his class and they would work hard to get it and they would ask for advice on how to get it.
Badger1777
Green Belt
- Joined
- Aug 15, 2014
- Messages
- 127
- Reaction score
- 58
How long have you been at this club?
I sometimes think it takes a few months to really get a feel for a club. I find that sometimes I feel like I don't agree with such and such a strategy, and then suddenly, lots of things just fall into place in one lesson and the previous few weeks suddenly make perfect sense.
If your school is rushing people through their grades, I wouldn't be worried about it, IF people are being made to work for them. If you think grading is just a box ticking exercise then its time to find a new club. If they push you fast because they are simply trying to show you just what you can achieve if you are determined enough, then that can only be a good thing.
Do I clarify when they sign up? Yes, I do.
Are they clear on how rank progresses? Yes, crystal clear. They are also crystal clear on asking about promotions - automatic six months longer because of the question. No exceptions.
I disagree on the "shut up and train" as only for drilling. First and foremost it is an attitude. IMO, a very important attitude. They are clear on this as well. Crystal.
I'm not saying this is the only way or the best way, it's just my way.
EddieCyrax
Blue Belt
Questions.....
What rank are you? How long have you trained? Do you have any other MA experience? What art are you currently training in?
Lots of variables here.
Early ranks tend to come on a regular basis.....but this slows down tremendously the higher you go.....(At least that is my experience with Kempo).
BJJ on the other hand ..... each rank is its own long journey.
What rank are you? How long have you trained? Do you have any other MA experience? What art are you currently training in?
Lots of variables here.
Early ranks tend to come on a regular basis.....but this slows down tremendously the higher you go.....(At least that is my experience with Kempo).
BJJ on the other hand ..... each rank is its own long journey.
My teachers have been pestering me to get the next belt for about twenty years or so now... darn mcdojo's. :lool:
So why is the attitude of "shut up and train" good outside of drills? Usually a good teacher not only welcomes questions but encourages them. I took a shooting class which you could say is a martial arts class of a sort and during drills we would shut up and train but before we would break for lunch our instructor wanted at least two questions from the class.
Danny T
Senior Master
I already asked why you would not speak with your instructor. There has been several opinions as to the topic. You need to know and understand what is the purpose for belt promotions at the different levels 'at your school'? What is the criteria used 'at your school' to test or to meet the standard for the purpose of belt promotions.
I ask what it actually is and not for what your opinion as to what it should be. Promotions are used for a number of reasons and not every school or organization uses the same goals or criteria.
In my school students have to test for their white sash, in most the white is 'given' to them just for signing up.
Obviously then, my criteria for the white belt is different than some others. I also have 3 different levels for white belt so one can also achieve the belt and 2 different stripes. The same through out the different colors.
Many for what I've read and seen. Say Black Belt is where one now is ready to start learning. The BB it seems is deemed to be the point one has learned and has a good grasp of the basics. For me this is a much lower level than what we use for BB. One must be highly proficient in skill, knowledge, and ability to use the techniques, the movements and positions from the forms in several different applications and explain what was done and why it was performed in that manner.
The jest of this is, promotions, rank, belts, stripes, are used by schools for a multitude of reasons. Know what is the purpose and what is the criteria for the different promotions before forming an opinion.
